Canadian Dimension - For people who want to change the world Subscribe Now!
CD blog

in the rooms where we gather…

Janette Watt, July 5th, 2007

It was last Tuesday, but it could just as well have been Wednesday.
I sat in a room filled with people, talking.
We had gathered in the name of doing justice.
We had gathered with the purpose of making change.
We had gathered each of us believing
that we had something individually to contribute.
I believe that is why we were all there. I don’t know.
Not everyone talked.
We left, some of us having talked.
There was some nodding, but very little understanding.

And, when we left the room Tuesday
where we were in relation to the world
was where we were on Monday.

How could this be? Why are things not different?
Why is there still injustice?
These are good people who want to make change
– passionate people, smart people –
those who have gathered.
How could this be?

It was last Wednesday, but it could just as well have been Thursday.
I sat in a room half-filled with people talking.
We had gathered in the name of anti-oppression struggles
We had gathered with the purpose of setting each other free
We had gathered each of us believing
that we had something individually to contribute.
I believe that is why we were all there. I don’t know.
Not everyone talked.
We left, some of us having talked.
There was some nodding, but very little understanding.

And, when we left the room Wednesday
where we were in relation to the world
was where we were on Tuesday.

How could this be? Why are things not different?
Why is there still oppression?
These are good people who want to make change
– passionate people, smart people –
those who have gathered (although there are less!)
How could this be?

It was last Thursday, but it could just as well have been Friday.
I sat in a room with some people, talking –
much fewer now.
We had gathered in the name of freedom,
freedom from alienation,
freedom from despair,
freedom from uncertainty.
We had gathered each of us believing
that we had something individually to contribute.
I believe that is why we were all there. I don’t know.
Not everyone talked.
We left, some of us having talked – but not all.

There was some nodding, but very little understanding.
And, when we left the room Thursday
where we were in relation to the world
was where we were on Wednesday.

How could this be? Why are things not different?
Why is there still alienation, despair and uncertainty?
These are good people who want to make change
– passionate people, smart people –
those who have gathered (although there are even less!)
How could this be?

It was last Friday, but it could just as well have been anyday.
I sat in a room with two people,
one was talking –
We had gathered in the name of democracy.
The one who was talking was angry and said,
“Where are the others who once came?
What is wrong with them?
Why are they not here any longer?
Do they not know that they should contribute?”
There was some nodding, but very little understanding.
And, when the two left the room on Friday
where we were in relation to the world
was where we were on Tuesday, or was it Monday?

It was anyday.
And no one came to the room.
No one gathered,
Not in this room or any room,
Not one of the good, passionate, smart people gathered in a room.
How could this be?

For justice to be done,
For there to be
no more oppression,
for there to be
freedom from alienation,
freedom from despair,
freedom from uncertainty,
For there to be real change
…it MUST happen with US first
in the rooms where we gather.

We must ALL gather,
ALL have voice,
ALL talk and ALL listen,
there must be every attempt at understanding…
and then there will be the change we hope for.

…it’s happening in some rooms,
but not all.
…not enough,
not yet.

Justice demands integrity… to have a moral universe… ~ bell hooks

Janette Watt Janette Watt is a proud-brazen-instigator, a value-driven political thinker, a social critic and an aspiring dissident writer. Her writing and her presentations are informed by her life experiences as an activist lawyer, an activist educator and active member of the human race. She is the owner/president of Watt Communications. Read other posts by Janette Watt.

8 Comments

  1. It remimds me of a quote, “All action no theory” and of those who do their day to day living without questioning why they are doing these actions. I’ve found recently that many people *want* to do good deeds until that is they have to return to work the next day.

    I suppose, now that I’ve said that, the opposite is worse. Having all theory and no action is as useless as a third nipple.

  2. it doesn’t happen in rooms. The rooms make us hope that it can happen in rooms, but things seldom do.
    Action happens outside the room, where people don’t need to wear the right cologne or eat the perfect salad afterwards.

    It seems to happen between the rooms, in the corridors of life, with or without a roof, running water, the right jargon.

    We meet in a room only to share what we’ve been doing outside. We meet to rejuvenate our energies, to replenish our drive. But then we leave the room to work.

  3. Is it possible that the writer’s notions of justice and freedom are not shared by those leaving the room? Perhaps the writer should stop meddling in a world that really doesn’t want her contribution. God save us from utopians.

  4. Really, the author needs to get out of that room and look around in order to appreciate the progress that the world is making.

    400 years of conflict in Northern Ireland ended just recently. A recent UN report (I’ll look for the study and get back to you with a cited source)documents a diminishing number of international conflicts over the past 20 years and a diminishing number of deaths resulting from violent conflict.

    200 years ago, 80 percent of the world’s population starved while 20% ate. Those ratio’s are currently reversed. While poverty is not going to end now, the means are in place to bring about its eventual abolition — international trade regimens, World Bank and IMF activities (same study as above).

    Meanwhile, the author and this publication attack institutions that are the best hope for the resolution of injustice and oppression. Not that either of you influence the world in any way, but consider just sitting quietly by to watch progress unfold.

  5. “In the Rooms Where we Gather.”

    I feel that your reflection about personal change is a challenge that involves personal transformation and action. A process that will allow people to take a strong stand to stop the increasing violence in the world. I value your call for action, not only for people who attend peace meetings, but for everybody that can contribute to achieve peace.

    Clara Jimeno

  6. Dear Blue

    …that’s my point. Those of us who want to “help” need to genuinely consider our own actions when we question why people do not enter discussions, or leave discussions. Reasons include those you give.

  7. Dear Jim

    I understand your point, and like you am grateful for the progress that we have made and continue to make. My point is that some of us, in our efforts to “help make change” act in ways that exclude some of the voices that need to be heard and acted on in order to make real sustainable change.

    The “us” who exclude ARE individuals or groups, and yes, institutions.

    To say we can do better is not to negate what we have done. That said, thank you for reminding us of the gains that have been made. It IS important to remember.

    Now, let’s make the world even better, for all of us — for those who are sold into slavery, for those in war torn countries, for those where there is no clean water, — together shall we?

  8. Still waiting for that cited source Jimbo….

Leave a Comment

Progressive Bloggers Part of the Progressive Bloggers Network.

Top of page